SHOP OUR COLLECTION

Welcome to Forgotten Spells

I came back to Magic after a long break, ready to dive into Commander — only to find out that building a competitive deck meant spending hundreds of dollars on cards I'd never be able to afford. So I did what any reasonable person would do: I made my own.

Forgotten Spells was born out of a love for the game and a refusal to let a price tag decide what you get to play. Every card we make is handcrafted with care, so you can build any deck, cast any spell, and show up to Commander night with exactly the cards you want — without emptying your wallet.

Whether you're looking for staples, lands, Secret Lair art, or precon upgrades, we've got you covered.

Shop the Collection →
Learn more about us and how we make our cards →

Shop By Collection
Secret Lair MTG proxy cards, Jodah the Unifier

SECRET LAIR

Land Sets MTG proxy cards, borderless Tundra

LAND SETS

Staple Card Packs MTG proxy cards, Sol Ring

STAPLE CARD PACKS

Game Changers MTG proxy cards, Rhystic Study

GAME CHANGERS

Lord of the Rings / The Hobbit MTG proxy cards

Lord of the Rings / The Hobbit

What Our Customers Say

ForgottenSpellsProxy on Etsy: 4.8 stars from 190 reviews, 1.3k sales

Real reviews from our Etsy shop

“cards are sooo cute!!! amazing quality too, and thank you so much for the few extras you threw in. i loved the totoro sticker, i actually have a totoro tattoo so this made my day 🥹”
Lindsay · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x Stardew Valley
“Really surprised with how this order came out. I will be purchasing more from this seller. 10/10”
Cameron C. · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x The Hobbit: Second Breakfast
“Exactly what was described PLUS a couple little related goodies. Got 2 fantastic fanart proxies that werent advertised but very much appriciated.”
Anthony F. · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair: Hatsune Miku Commander Deck
“I was expecting cardstock tokens but its more of a laminated type of material, which is great for durability!”
Zenaida · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x The Hobbit: Second Breakfast
“Extreamly fast shipping and super protective packaging. Cards are great quality and bonus gift included. Highly recommended.”
Chris · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x The Hobbit: Book Cover Set
“Absolutely amazing quality! The art style was perfect!”
Jessica M. · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x Cats are the Best: Purr Majesty
“Feel great. Fine a new place get secret lair past sets and current sets. Plus didn't have wait in online for cards.”
Joshua E. · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x Dungeons & Black Lights
“Super fast and great quality. I missed out on secret lair by an hour and was excited to still be able to get this for a gift!”
Matthew M. · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x The Hobbit: Second Breakfast
“great quality, highly recommended!”
Ricardo · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x The Hobbit: Book Cover Set
“super friendly experience, highly recommend”
Tom M. · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x Jaws
“Good product, fast shipping; would buy from them again.”
Nicholas · Verified Etsy reviewSecret Lair x Lord of the Rings
“A+ Perfect Love the purchase”
Rogelio · Verified Etsy reviewDual Lands Proxy Set
Read more reviews on Etsy